A Look Back: Where it All Began
The journey of the 5.7x28mm cartridge, and consequently, the handguns that fire it, is intertwined with the evolution of modern military and law enforcement needs. FN Herstal, a renowned arms manufacturer based in Belgium, pioneered this concept.
The FN Five-seveN, bearing the same name, was conceived to fulfill a specific requirement: a personal defense weapon (PDW) capable of penetrating body armor. FN aimed to provide a lightweight and compact firearm that could effectively engage targets at extended ranges, offering a significant advantage in scenarios where standard handgun rounds might falter. This led to the development of both the cartridge and the firearm. The FN Five-seveN quickly found its place in the world, becoming a favorite among certain military and law enforcement agencies for its capacity, flat trajectory, and armor piercing capability.
The Ruger 57, on the other hand, represents a different approach. Ruger, a prominent American firearms manufacturer, saw the potential of the 5.7x28mm round for a broader market. Instead of targeting the tactical realm exclusively, they focused on offering a more accessible and affordable alternative for civilian shooters. This shift in focus is reflected in the design philosophy: the Ruger 57 prioritizes ergonomics and value while maintaining the inherent performance advantages of the 5.7x28mm cartridge.
Examining the Hardware: Features and Design
The differences between the Ruger 57 and the FN Five-seveN are more than just a matter of pedigree. Careful examination reveals distinct characteristics that influence the shooting experience.
Both pistols leverage the 5.7x28mm cartridge, a round known for its high velocity and relatively low recoil. This shared foundation provides a unique set of benefits, including a flat trajectory that enhances accuracy at longer distances and reduced muzzle rise during firing, allowing for faster follow-up shots. However, the specifics of each firearm’s design dictate how these advantages are harnessed.
The FN Five-seveN presents a distinct profile, often characterized by its polymer frame and sleek, almost futuristic, appearance. The build quality of the FN Five-seveN is renowned; it’s a robust firearm designed for durability. The ergonomics are generally considered comfortable, although some shooters might find the grip slightly blocky compared to more modern designs. The controls, including the slide release, safety, and magazine release, are well-placed and relatively easy to manipulate.
The Ruger 57, in contrast, adopts a more contemporary aesthetic. It incorporates a polymer frame, complemented by a steel slide, resulting in a more balanced feel in hand. The Ruger 57’s ergonomics are particularly noteworthy, with a grip that is well-contoured and comfortable for a wide range of hand sizes. The controls are intuitive, the slide release and magazine release are easy to access, and the overall design feels streamlined and modern.
Understanding the Details: Controls, Construction, and More
Beyond the broad strokes, a deeper dive into the details reveals further distinctions.
The FN Five-seveN is known for its robust construction, using high-quality polymers and internal components designed for long-term reliability. It often feels very solid and built to withstand demanding use. The controls are generally well-placed and easy to operate. However, the specific layout might require some acclimation for shooters accustomed to other pistol platforms.
The Ruger 57, in contrast, often presents a blend of modern manufacturing techniques and an emphasis on value. Its polymer frame, while still durable, might feel slightly less substantial than the FN’s design. Ergonomically, the Ruger 57 excels. The grip texture and overall design are exceptionally comfortable. The controls are designed to be easily accessible, even for shooters with smaller hands.
The sights play a critical role in achieving accurate shot placement. The FN Five-seveN generally features adjustable iron sights that provide a clear sight picture. Some models may be optic-ready, offering the possibility of adding a red dot sight for enhanced target acquisition. The Ruger 57 typically comes equipped with adjustable iron sights, providing a similar level of accuracy. Mounting options for optics are readily available on certain Ruger 57 models, expanding the potential for customization.
Trigger characteristics are crucial to overall shooting performance. The FN Five-seveN typically features a trigger with a crisp break and a moderate pull weight. While not a match-grade trigger, it’s generally considered good for its intended purpose. The Ruger 57’s trigger feel can vary; it’s often lighter and smoother. Overall, the trigger will be more accurate.
Magazine capacity is an important consideration for many shooters. Both handguns offer a generous amount of ammunition, but the specific capacity varies depending on the magazine. The FN Five-seveN’s magazine holds a respectable amount. The Ruger 57 often provides a larger magazine capacity.
The Shooting Experience: On the Range
The true test of any firearm lies in the shooting experience. Both the Ruger 57 and the FN Five-seveN provide a distinct and enjoyable shooting experience.
The high velocity of the 5.7x28mm cartridge results in minimal felt recoil. This enables rapid follow-up shots and a greater degree of control. The flat trajectory of the bullets contributes to increased accuracy at extended ranges. The ergonomics and trigger of each pistol contribute greatly to how they feel.
The Ruger 57 offers a shooting experience that is particularly user-friendly. The ergonomic design and relatively smooth trigger contribute to a comfortable and controlled shooting experience. The low recoil allows for rapid and accurate follow-up shots, making it a popular choice for both recreational shooting and self-defense.
The FN Five-seveN also provides a pleasurable experience. The sights and feel of the firearm, with the solid feel and robust construction, enhances the perception of quality. The low recoil makes it a very easy gun to control. The flat trajectory can also produce a good shot for longer ranges.
The Good and The Bad: Weighing the Advantages
Each handgun possesses its own set of strengths and weaknesses.
The Ruger 57 shines as an exceptionally affordable choice. Its modern ergonomics and well-designed controls provide a comfortable and intuitive shooting experience. The high magazine capacity is appealing. Aftermarket support and customization options are readily available. It’s a great entry point into the 5.7x28mm platform. The trigger could be improved; some shooters might prefer a higher-quality feel.
The FN Five-seveN brings with it a reputation for exceptional build quality and reliability. The reputation of the firearm is second to none. Its sleek design and well-placed controls are appealing. The reputation makes the pistol well-respected in the industry. However, cost is a major factor for many. Aftermarket support isn’t as extensive as with the Ruger 57. Some shooters may find the ergonomics less ideal.
Making the Right Call: Which is Right for You?
Deciding between the Ruger 57 and the FN Five-seveN hinges on your individual needs.
If budget is a primary consideration, the Ruger 57 presents a compelling value proposition. If you’re seeking an accessible entry point into the 5.7x28mm platform with excellent ergonomics and high capacity, the Ruger 57 is a strong contender. This is ideal for casual shooting or self-defense.
For shooters who prioritize top-tier build quality, legacy, and a design that’s field-tested, the FN Five-seveN holds its ground. The FN Five-seveN is often the choice for someone who has specific requirements in mind or values a certain reputation.
Conclusion
The Ruger 57 and the FN Five-seveN each offer a unique and compelling experience within the 5.7x28mm platform. The FN Five-seveN stands out. The Ruger 57 offers its own benefits.
The best way to make a final decision is to try to handle and shoot both firearms if possible. By understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each, you can confidently choose the handgun that best aligns with your needs and preferences. The goal is finding a firearm that is reliable, easy to use, and enjoyable to shoot.
