The Glock 23: An Overview
The Glock 23: A name synonymous with reliability, power, and the compact handgun market. Chambered in the potent .40 Smith & Wesson caliber, it has served as a staple for law enforcement, military personnel, and civilian self-defense practitioners for decades. The evolution of the Glock 23, like its other Glock counterparts, has seen several iterations, each building upon the successes of its predecessors. Today, we’ll delve into a thorough comparison, pitting two prominent generations against each other: the Glock 23 Gen 5 and the Glock 23 Gen 4. This analysis aims to provide you with the information needed to make an informed decision about which Glock 23 best suits your individual needs, highlighting the advancements, and discussing the practical implications of each generation.
Gen 4 Glock 23: Decoding the Features
The Gen 4 Glock 23, a pivotal point in the Glock’s evolution, brought forth a series of notable refinements. One of the most noticeable changes was the introduction of the Rough Texture Frame, often referred to as the RTF or Gen 4 texture. This enhanced grip texture significantly improved the shooter’s purchase on the firearm, particularly in wet or challenging conditions.
Another important aspect of the Gen 4 was the inclusion of interchangeable backstraps. Glock recognized that hand sizes vary widely, and provided these different backstraps to give the user a customizable grip. This modularity enabled shooters to fine-tune the grip’s circumference, enhancing comfort and control.
A significant mechanical upgrade in the Gen 4 was the dual recoil spring assembly. This system aimed to mitigate felt recoil and enhance the pistol’s longevity. This design improved the overall shooting experience by reducing muzzle climb and felt recoil, making the Gen 4 a bit easier to manage during rapid firing sequences.
Additionally, the Gen 4 Glock 23 featured a reversible magazine release. This alteration catered to both right- and left-handed shooters, allowing them to easily and effectively release the magazine without having to re-grip the firearm.
Considering the specs of the Gen 4, they generally include: a weight, unloaded, around a specific amount; a total length, including the barrel; a height, measured from the base of the magazine to the top of the sights; the width of the slide; and a magazine capacity, typically holding a number of rounds. The barrel length remains a consistent aspect.
Gen 5 Glock 23: Examining the Advancements
The Gen 5 Glock 23 continued the evolution of the model, building upon the Gen 4’s successes and introducing a new set of improvements. Perhaps the most immediate visual change is the inclusion of front slide serrations. These serrations, positioned on the front of the slide, provide additional gripping points, facilitating easier manipulation of the slide, especially when performing press checks or racking the slide under pressure.
A major internal upgrade within the Gen 5 is the Glock Marksman Barrel, commonly referred to as the GMB. The GMB is engineered to offer a more consistent and precise barrel lock-up, potentially enhancing accuracy. This upgrade represents a significant step forward in terms of mechanical precision, aimed at improving shot grouping and overall performance.
Continuing with the trend of user-centric design, the Gen 5 featured an ambidextrous slide stop lever. This design allows for seamless operation by both right- and left-handed shooters, providing increased convenience and versatility in operation. This feature eliminates any disadvantage that left-handed shooters may have experienced in prior models.
Another notable change was the removal of finger grooves on the grip. While the finger grooves on the Gen 4 were intended to enhance grip, some users found that the grooves did not align with their hand size. The Gen 5’s streamlined grip, without the finger grooves, provides a more universal fit, allowing for a more natural and comfortable hold for a wider range of shooters.
The trigger system also saw improvements in the Gen 5. The pull and feel were refined, aimed at providing a crisper break and shorter reset. This improvement contributes to more accurate and controlled shooting.
Finally, the Gen 5 grip texture was enhanced. The new texture is a subtle, yet effective improvement over the Gen 4, providing a more secure and stable grip without being overly abrasive.
The Gen 5, much like its predecessor, has its own specific weight, unloaded, overall length, height, width, and magazine capacity. The barrel length remains consistent.
Direct Comparison: Gen 5 Versus Gen 4
When placing the Gen 5 and Gen 4 Glock 23 side-by-side, the differences become more evident. The frame and ergonomics are immediately noticeable. The grip texture is noticeably different. The Gen 5 provides a slightly more aggressive and tactile grip texture, enhancing the shooter’s ability to maintain control, even with wet hands. The removal of the finger grooves on the Gen 5 is another key difference, providing a more neutral grip and offering a more uniform fit for a wider range of shooters.
The slide and controls also exhibit key distinctions. The front slide serrations on the Gen 5 are a welcome addition, particularly for those who prefer front slide manipulation. The ambidextrous slide stop, a feature absent on the Gen 4, adds to the Gen 5’s overall ease of use.
The Glock Marksman Barrel is a major advantage for the Gen 5. The GMB offers the potential for enhanced accuracy.
The trigger feel represents a refined experience in the Gen 5. The Gen 5’s trigger pull is typically smoother.
Recoil management is another consideration. The Gen 5 maintains the solid recoil management of the Gen 4.
Performance: A Look at the Real World
While theoretical specifications and features are important, the true test of a firearm lies in its practical performance. In the real world, both the Gen 4 and Gen 5 Glock 23s exhibit inherent reliability. The .40 S&W caliber itself contributes to a noticeable, but manageable recoil impulse.
Shooting both generations side-by-side, one can experience the difference in ergonomics. The Gen 5’s more neutral grip can feel more comfortable for some. Accuracy improvements are sometimes seen.
The Pros and Cons: Weighing the Options
The advantages and disadvantages of each generation are crucial for making an informed decision. The Gen 5 brings a series of enhancements, including its improved accuracy, better trigger, ambidextrous slide stop, and front slide serrations. The Gen 5 offers an overall refined shooting experience. However, these enhancements may come at a higher price.
The Gen 4, on the other hand, provides a more budget-friendly option. Gen 4’s key benefits include a lower cost and the availability of a wider range of accessories and holsters. For those on a budget, the Gen 4 is a proven, reliable option. However, some may find the finger grooves of the Gen 4 not ideal.
Making the Right Choice: Which Glock 23 Is Best For You?
Deciding between the Gen 4 and Gen 5 comes down to individual needs.
For first-time Glock buyers, the Gen 4 is a solid choice, especially given its lower price point and established reputation.
Experienced Glock owners may appreciate the refinements of the Gen 5, particularly the improved accuracy, and its overall ergonomic design.
For concealed carry, both generations are suitable, but the preference often depends on individual grip preference and tolerance for the slightly more aggressive texture. The Gen 5’s enhanced grip could be beneficial for those who may encounter harsh conditions.
For competitive shooting, the improved accuracy and trigger on the Gen 5 may provide an advantage.
The Conclusion
In summary, both the Glock 23 Gen 5 and Gen 4 are outstanding firearms that have earned their place in the world of self-defense. The Gen 5 brings a series of incremental improvements in accuracy, ergonomics, and handling. The Gen 4 is a proven and reliable choice.
The best choice depends entirely on your personal preferences, budget, and intended use. Consider the factors discussed above to make an informed decision. We encourage you to handle and, if possible, shoot both models to truly determine which one feels best in your hands. This in-person experience will be the most important aspect of choosing the Glock 23 that is perfect for you.
