The Upsides of Packing Extra Rounds
Increased Capacity
One of the most immediate advantages of a 1911 with extended mag is the increase in ammunition capacity. Standard 1911 magazines typically hold between seven and ten rounds, depending on caliber and configuration. An extended magazine, however, can significantly boost that number, often reaching twelve, fourteen, or even more rounds. This expanded capacity can be a crucial advantage in several scenarios. In a defensive situation, every extra round gives you more chances to neutralize a threat and protect yourself or your loved ones. The increased number of shots available can also contribute to peace of mind, knowing you have a greater resource at your disposal should the need arise.
Improved Reload Efficiency
Another significant benefit of using a 1911 with extended mag is the potential for improved reload efficiency. The extended basepad of the magazine typically protrudes further from the grip, creating a larger surface area to grab during a reload. This makes it easier to grasp and insert the magazine quickly and smoothly, reducing the time it takes to get back into the fight. Faster reloads are a crucial skill in any situation where you might need to replenish your ammunition supply under pressure.
Enhanced Grip and Handling (in some cases)
In some cases, an extended magazine can also enhance the grip and handling of the 1911. The extended basepad can provide a more secure and comfortable grip surface, particularly for shooters with larger hands. This added gripping surface can potentially improve control and recoil management, allowing for faster follow-up shots and better accuracy. However, this advantage depends on the specific design of the extended magazine and the shooter’s individual preferences.
The Potential Downsides: Considerations and Trade-offs
Increased Size and Concealment Issues
One of the most significant disadvantages is the increase in size. The magazine extends below the grip, making the pistol longer overall. This can present concealment challenges for those who prioritize concealed carry. The extended magazine is more likely to print through clothing, and it can also be less comfortable to carry, especially if you’re sitting or bending frequently.
Reliability Concerns
Reliability is also a critical concern with extended magazines. While many reputable manufacturers produce high-quality extended mags, some can be less reliable than standard magazines, particularly when they are new or paired with certain types of ammunition. The longer spring and increased capacity can sometimes lead to feeding issues if not designed and manufactured properly. It’s crucial to choose extended magazines from trusted brands known for reliability and to thoroughly test them with your chosen ammunition before relying on them for self-defense.
Aesthetics and Balance
Aesthetically, some shooters are not fond of the look of a 1911 with extended mag. The extended magazine can change the classic lines of the 1911 pistol, disrupting the traditional balance and proportions. This is a subjective concern, of course, and some shooters find the extended magazine to be an appealing and functional addition to their firearm.
Price
The price of extended magazines is another factor to consider. Extended magazines often cost more than standard magazines, which can add up, especially if you are purchasing several to equip multiple firearms or to have spares. When building out a reliable magazine setup, make sure you allocate the proper budget.
Making the Right Choice: Factors to Consider
Reliability Factors
First and foremost, reliability is paramount. Look for brands known for manufacturing reliable magazines. Respected brands invest in rigorous testing. Reading online reviews from other shooters can provide valuable insights into the real-world performance and reliability of specific magazine models. Break-in procedures are also very important, following manufacturer instructions to ensure that the magazine functions flawlessly. Testing the extended magazine thoroughly with your chosen ammunition is crucial before relying on it for self-defense.
Capacity vs. Concealability
The intended use is a vital factor in determining the suitability of an extended magazine. If concealability is a top priority, the increased size of an extended magazine might be a significant disadvantage, and you might consider a standard-capacity magazine or a different carry method. For competitive shooters or those in tactical roles, where capacity and speed are essential, the advantages of an extended magazine may outweigh the drawbacks. Determine what you need from your 1911 and build around those needs.
Compatibility
Magazine compatibility is crucial. Ensure the extended magazine is compatible with your specific 1911 model and caliber. Some extended magazines are designed for specific frame sizes or feature variations, so confirm that the magazine will fit and function correctly. Some extended magazines will be made for .45 ACP, while others can be designed for 9mm.
Quality of Materials and Construction
The quality of materials and construction also has a direct impact on the magazine’s performance and longevity. Look for extended magazines made from high-quality materials like stainless steel or durable polymer. Examine the follower and spring. Make sure the follower is designed to feed rounds smoothly and reliably and that the spring is strong enough to provide consistent feeding and ejection, even when the magazine is fully loaded. The basepad should be securely attached and durable enough to withstand the rigors of frequent use and reloads.
Other Features
Consider additional features that may enhance the performance and ease of use of the magazine. Some extended magazines feature a textured basepad that provides a more secure grip during reloads. The basepad itself can make a difference in how it feels and handles.
Top Picks: Leading Extended Magazine Options
Wilson Combat
Wilson Combat has a long-standing reputation for producing high-quality 1911 components. Their extended magazines are known for their reliability and durability. They use robust construction and feature strong springs for flawless feeding.
Capacity: Typically holds between 10 and 14 rounds, depending on the model and caliber.
Materials: Constructed from high-quality stainless steel and feature reliable polymer basepads.
Key Features: The magazines often use Wilson Combat’s proprietary follower design for enhanced feeding reliability.
Pros: Extremely reliable, well-built, and trusted by many experienced shooters.
Cons: May be slightly more expensive than some other options.
Tripp Research
Tripp Research offers a line of extended magazines that are highly regarded for their performance and innovative design. These magazines are known for their exceptional reliability and feeding characteristics.
Capacity: Typically holds between 10 and 12 rounds.
Materials: Constructed from high-quality stainless steel with proprietary anti-friction coatings.
Key Features: They feature innovative anti-tilt followers that help prevent feeding problems.
Pros: Highly reliable, designed for excellent feeding, and built to last.
Cons: While a top choice, may be slightly higher priced than some alternatives.
Chip McCormick
Chip McCormick magazines are a popular choice among competition shooters. They are known for their reliability, smooth feeding, and excellent performance.
Capacity: Typically holds between 10 and 14 rounds.
Materials: Made from high-quality steel and feature durable followers.
Key Features: The design is focused on smooth feeding and enhanced reliability under demanding conditions.
Pros: Great for competition use, known for reliability and smooth feeding.
Cons: The baseplates can be somewhat flimsy.
Remember to research and compare options, read reviews, and make your selection based on your specific needs and preferences.
Wrapping Up: Finding the Right Fit
Ultimately, the decision to equip your 1911 with extended mag is a personal one, determined by your individual needs and priorities. The advantages—increased capacity, faster reloads, and potentially improved control—can be significant, particularly in self-defense, competition shooting, and tactical applications. However, the drawbacks, including increased size, potential reliability concerns, and the aesthetic impact, should also be carefully considered.
If you prioritize capacity and speed and are less concerned about absolute concealability, an extended magazine might be an excellent choice. If you value concealment above all else, a standard-capacity magazine might be a better fit. If you are building a gun for self-defense, remember to train and maintain your firearm regularly. Whatever your preference, it’s essential to thoroughly research different magazine options, prioritize reliability, and test the magazine with your chosen ammunition to ensure optimal performance. The best approach is to evaluate your needs and make an informed decision.
